These are
what we’d consider “budget” Humbucker bobbins – and, maybe, that’s overly harsh
on what is, essentially, a hunk of injection molded plastic, but, for the sake
of honesty – this version simply aren’t as well made as our usual Humbucker bobbins
Available in Slug and Screw type, 52 and 50mm pole spacing, and in Black,
White, Ivory, Blue, Pink, Green, Orange and Chrome.
Why are the budget?
In short, whilst they’re actually finished to a decent standard, and their size
and shape are “correct” – the holes are oversized to what they should be, and
this isn’t going to make your life easy frankly.
The main “problems” are as follows.
The pole holes on the slug bobbins are slightly oversized – they are 4.9mm
diameter, rather then 3/16”, so, obviously, a standard 3/16” (4.75mm) humbucker pole is simply going to fall through.
And
The pole holes
in the screw bobbins are, also, slightly oversize – they’re coming in at 2.9mm –
so there isn’t quite enough “meat” for an M3 bolt to bite into the material and
engage the thread (remember, M3 bolts aren’t 3mm… Metric threads have “effective
diameters”, and on an M3 bolt? That’s 2.7mm)
So, we can see exactly what’s happened here I suppose – an injection molding
factory have been commissioned to make these things, they’ve assumed 5mm and
3mm holes, rather then “holes for” 3/16” and M3.
And, honestly? Normally, I wouldn’t have touched these with a barge pole,
because we subscribe to the “if its not right, its not OK” way of thinking,
and, whilst they “budget” (and certainly not likely to be the greatest money
spinner Axes has indulged in!) – they’re not really that cheap (I wish they
were cheaper frankly!) – slightly cheaper than the “good” bobbins, certainly,
but not exactly the steal of the century (and the problems are going to cost
you more time, and if your winding pickups for a living? Please, get the good
bobbins! Save the headache!)
So, why have we got them?
To put it bluntly – its because they’re available in mad colours and in small
quantities!
The “good” bobbin factory will do any colour we want (and we already do a
decent range in those!) but the minimum order quantity is in the thousands.
These bobbins? The Minimum quantity we have to buy, is 20!
Now, as much as I’d love to carry Pink, Blue, orange and yellow bobbins in the “right”
bobbins – it isn’t happening. It’s a niche part, seldom requested, and, considering we DO carry
them in Red, Purple and Green? I know that, really, they weird colors don’t
sell in thousands unfortunately - we aren't taking the risk.
So, the budget bobbins that aren’t quite right BUT they come in weird colours
and small quantities?! I can overlook the niggles, and if you can too? Maybe
not they're worst thing in the world!
And that’s basically the long and short of it – if you’ve been commissioned to
wind a pair of pink and green humbucker, need the bobbins tomorrow, and can
make it work with less the perfectly sized holes? Your in luck!
How to make it work
As drastic as I’m making this sound, its not hard to bodge it into a workable
situation thankfully.
Screw side – 5/40 bolts are your best friend! 3.1mm effective diameter is going
to fit into those holes without any problem – such an easy fix, its not really
worth worrying about really.
Slug side – super glue! Slugs in bobbin, blob of superglue on the back of the
bobbin, let it cure, and they’re in there. They’re not going to be centralized,
but its not all that noticeable.
The “logical”
solution would have been use design a 5mm slug pole to go in there, but that
actually doesn’t work believe it or not – the way humbuckers are designed, to
have both bobbins “meet” in the middle, means you use a 12.5mm wide bar magnet,
a 3/16” (4.75mm) slug and under the screw bobbin sits in a 4.75mm keeper bar – which
gives you a “pole to pole” width of 17.25mm between the two bobbins – and with
humbuckers bobbins being 17.5mm wide, that’s 0.25mm “wiggle room” to get
everything lined up properly. The under carriage of a humbucker needs that
0.25mm spare to align everything and account for variance in manufacturing tolerances
between slug/magnet/keeper bar manufacturers - so, a 5mm slug wouldn’t actually
work! (Furthermore, it’d likely deform the bobbins hole too – its 4.9mm top to
bottom, the “good” bobbins are 4.75mm top to bottom, but have a small flange in
the middle that holds the slugs in place – that flange isn’t present on the
budget bobbins.)
In Closing
Wouldn’t be
my first choice of bobbin personally, and if I was wanting a colour that was
available in the good bobbins? That’s what I’d use, all day long – BUT, if you
need mad colours? The budgets are about the only choice you’ve got I’m afraid! Not the worst things in the world, and certainly opens up scope for some crazy colour combos, but they wouldn't be my first choice if i was assembling 100 humbuckers and looking for perfection, for that? Its the good ones!
They are too, cosmetically, similar enough to our usual bobbins to be used side
by side – so you can use them both on the same humbuckers.